Monday, June 10, 2013

The Political Storm that threatens the Democratic Dignity of Bhutan.

Today the Bhutanese Media confirmed that the highest echelon of Druk Nyamrup Tshogpa Political Party ( DNT ) are now part of People’s Democratic Party ( PDP ). The highest echelon includes the President, the Vice President, a prominent original promoter of DNT and another DNT winner. And four other DNT candidates are piggybacked to the four sought after Candidates to strengthen DNT’s hand within the Party Alliance with PDP.

Impact of the Party Alliance.

1)  This reduces the original DNT to the same status as Druk Chirwang Tshogpa ( DCT ) Political Party or even worse because without its high command DNT is reduced into a nonexistent Entity. The face of the Party has been taken away and the major part of the 17.5% primary votes goes with the Candidates who have switched over.

2)   This merger of 8 DNT Candidates with the PDP cannot be termed as Party Hopping or Opportunistic leap of registered Party members from one Political Party to another as permitted under Election Laws. The Election Law refers specifically to members of a registered Political Party. It does not refer to Constituency Candidates of a Political Party who are nominated, accepted and registered with the Election Commission of Bhutan ( ECB ) as Party Candidates.


3)   The complete switching over of Druk Nyamrup Tshogpa’s high command along with 5 other Candidates to the People’s Democratic Party definitely constitutes the formation of Political Parties Alliance. It is way beyond what the Election Law states i.e. resigning of registered members from one Political Party to join another Political Party and contest the General Elections.

4)    The formation of Political Party Alliance to contest the General Election poses a historic challenge to the Election Commission of Bhutan, the Institution of Judiciary in Bhutan and the Institution of Bhutanese Monarchy. As independent as the Election Commission of Bhutan is supposed to be, yet, it alone may not be able to give the approval or disapproval stamp to this emergence of Political Parties Alliance.


5)   When a Political Party receives around 18% of votes in the Primary Election, it represents nearly one-fifth of the Bhutanese population. How do we throttle the voice of 1/5th of the Nation? This is something more Bhutanese should have dwelt upon prior to the adoption of the Constitution.

6)   At the time of drafting the Constitution of Bhutan, I did point out in writing this dilemma if only 2 Political Parties are permitted to contest in the General Election. And now this dilemma is haunting Bhutan immediately after the 1st Primary Election held in the nation. In the year 2007 itself, I felt that the nation had a moral, social and political obligation to take into account any Political Party that receives over 15% of votes in the Primary Election and that was why I had appealed to the Chairman of the Constitution Drafting Committee that more than two Political Parties need to be considered for General Election. However, national wisdom stuck to 2 Political Parties and the Draft Constitution has been signed into Mother of Law by the first Parliament. And I don’t think it leaves any room for Political Alliance under whatever Shade and Colour. And if Election Commission chooses to interpret Election Law to suit political convenience than I think it would be less painful for the nation to terminate the tenure of Election Commissioners then have the process of Democracy murdered.

7)   As of this date, it would be unconstitutional for 3 Political Parties to participate in the present General Election. The Political Alliance of Druk Nyamrup Tshogpa and People’s Democratic Party under the banner of People’s Democratic Party is unconstitutional. The Druk Nyamrup Tshogpa has already publicly declared that their candidates even after joining another Political Party are expected to, “take DNT’s principles and concerns forward.”

8)     It is too late this time but this coming 2nd Parliament must amend the Constitution.

a)    Make provision for a 3rd Political Party to contest General Election. The result of the 1st Primary Election is sufficiently evident enough to substantiate the need for a 3rd Political Party in the General Election. It will also take care of domination of Bhutanese political scene by just one national Party.
b)   Otherwise do away with the nomination process of Political Party Candidates for the Primary Round of Election. Keep the Primary Election purely between POLITICAL PARTIES as it was meant to be and not between Political Party Constituency Candidates as has been encouraged by Election Commission.

9)  The Election Commission of Bhutan should never have over stepped its mandate. Why were the Political Parties required to identify and nominate 47 Candidates for 47 Constituencies when Primary Election was primarily for selection of two Political Parties to contest in the General Election from amongst numerous Political Parties? Even the BBS debate forum sponsored by ECB had pitched constituency candidates against each other. For Primary Election, one would have thought that 3 public debates would have been more than adequate: 1) Between Presidents of Political Parties, 2) Between Vice Presidents of Political Parties and 3) Between General Secretaries of Political Parties.

10) Things misfire and bring embarrassment to all because politics of convenience has been given a free rein. Is it now possible to clear this political mess and recoup democratic dignity? I think Bhutan and Bhutanese and our relevant authorities must think deeply.

11) Whatever we decide, please do not lay grounds for distrusts, shameful partiality and national discord. The people who make rules cannot keep bending the same continuously without harming the unity and stability of the Nation. It is time that we share the onus of responsible interpretation of Election Laws that ensures transparency into the process of Democracy. Democratic Reforms were introduced to avoid any future Public Discontent as so demonstrated in late 1980s in the Southern Region of the Nation. It is necessary now to look beyond the short-term political gain for any political faction. Bhutan and Bhutanese must avoid sowing seeds of public disillusionment that in the long run could adversely affect the social and political thought process of the populace. 

I personally do not think that the ongoing Political Alliance would actually make a big difference in the outcome of the General Election.  First PDP may suffer similar backlash as Druk Phuensum Tshogpa ( DPT ) suffered in Punakha and Haa for booting out old Candidates. And secondly the voters of DNT may have sincerely voted for New Times New Ideas and not Old Wine in Old Casket. If this presumption is true then voters especially those postal voters and other educated voters would have no further reasons to vote for the same Candidates. I also do not think PDP would have wanted as many as 8 DNT Candidates but maybe that was the only way to strike an Alliance deal with DNT. It would not have been possible especially for someone like Aum Dorji Choden the President of DNT to serve under a banner of another Political Party without substantial number of her own Party Candidates joining her. It would have been like a mother abandoning her infant baby to be in stride with her new Lover.


Friday, June 7, 2013

Who must Haaps thank for stopping the Dragong mining project?

In regards to the Facebook announcement made by Haa NC regarding the stoppage of proposed mining, let me put things in proper perspective. A few days back Dasho Dr. Gado contacted me. He said he had prevailed upon Mr. Pema Juney and RSA owner Mr. Rinchen Dorji to lift their equipments away from the proposed mining site. He told me that due to his busy campaign schedule, he was unable to take up the matter earlier. Dr. Gado himself had nothing to do with the project but since he was the DPT candidate, rumours had sprung up about him being a promoter of the mining project. He felt it was the rumour against him which cost him Katsho Geog votes. So in desperation he took up the matter with the mining company who agreed to remove their equipments. It is very possible that Mr. Pema Juney and Mr. Rinchen Dorji of RSA Company had realized that it would be futile to carry out exploratory mining works at huge financial cost since the public of Haa and the Local Government of Haa have already objected to it and was prepared to go to the highest authority of the land. Therefore it could not have been much of a pain for them to accede to Dr. Gado’s request.

Possibly Dasho Dr. Gado may have also informed about the development to Haa NC and therefore the announcement from Dasho Tshering Dorji’s side. The fact is that as of date, the Director General of Geology and Mines has not yet responded to the two letters sent by Haa Dzongkhag Administration and the Chairman of Haa Local Government.

Initially, the people of Lhayulkha Village approached the Dzongkhag Administration to stop the mining project. They also submitted an appeal letter to the Director General of DGM which was forwarded by the Dzongkhag Administration to DGM Office in Thimphu. However, a few days later, Dasho Dzongrab who was officiating as Dzongda issued an order to the Katsho Gup and Town Thuemi directing them to tell the Lhayulkha villagers that the project cannot be stopped since permission had already been granted. That stand by the Haa Dzongkhag Administration spooked the communities of Haa and they decided to join the people of Lhayulkha Village to stop the imminent destruction of local environment by the proposed mining project.

The people of Katsho Geog came together and approached the Geog Yargye Tshogdu (GYT) and led by the GYT members they approached the Chairman of Dzongkhag Yargye Tshogdu (DYT) and also the Dzongkhag Administration of Haa. They submitted a petition which in nutshell asked the respective leaders of the Local Government to stop the destructive mining project and if they are unable to carry out this task then let the people of Katsho Geog approach His Majesty the King. Both Dasho Dzongrab and the Chairman of Local Government addressed the gathering of over 250 household representatives and assured that the mining project would be stopped because it was against the decision of the Local Government to keep Haa as a Green Dzongkhag. Further the project did not have any clearance from the stakeholders and the Local Government.

The Dzongrab and the Chairman of Local Government have written to the Director General of DGM to stop the project even if it is purported to be exploratory in nature. The people were not buying this explanation. The letter from the DYT Thrizen was very explicit. It stated that the DYT had declared Haa Dzongkhag a green zone and a tourist destination for cultural and trekking tours. The stakeholders were never consulted and the Local Government was kept in the dark and the proposed mining project would destroy the most densely populated region of Haa Dzongkhag. Therefore DGM must stop this project immediately and instruct the project management to leave the site with their equipments. And if the Central Government insists on pushing the project then the Government must first complete the task of relocating all the villages, goenpas, two schools, hospital, army encampment and the Haa town.

To me it was unthinkable that the Government would go to such extreme length to destroy 50 years of development in Haa for the purpose of quenching the thirst of few money mongers. Therefore I was confident that the proposed mining project would be stopped sooner or later. And when it is stopped the people of Haa have to only thank themselves. It was the united efforts of the humble communities themselves that stood in defiance against the powerful forces behind the mining project. There is one person who must be really thanked and he is Samar Geog Gup Tshewang Tandin who is the Chairman of Local Government of Haa. I thank the Haa Deities Meri Phuensum and Ap Chundu for blessing the people of Haa with a surprising very honest capable and courageous Thrizen of DYT. I do not deserve any credit and I don’t think anyone else should also lay claim to what is rightfully the united achievement of the humble Haa communities consisting mainly of poor villagers who are rich in honesty and integrity.

During the recent visit of His Majesty the King and Her Majesty the Queen, the people of Haa were told by His Majesty that they were courageous, sensible and forthright and that Haa people have always been faithful to the Kings and the Country. I pray that the bond between the people of Haa and our Monarch remain as strong as ever and that may His Majesty protect the harmony of Haa community.


I am Apolitical but I do favour Policies strengthening National Sovereignty

This is in response to Kuensel Online comment referred to me by anonymous Goldenboy.

goldenboy dtd 5th June 2013
"Sir (Sangay Wangcha, Haa), from your statement it clearly indicates that you are a firm supporter of DPT without any doubt. And i respect your views for that but is Lyonchen immortal or will the country not sustain without him?It’s high time we embrace change, Lyonchen and the former ministers have done what was within their capacity and i thank them for that. But looking at the current situation of the country such as the rupee crisis, i feel that fresh brains could come up with new ideas of tackling the problem whereas the old lot cant think out of the box. And supporting a single party wouldn’t it be dangerous? As of date, from two oranges we have just tasted one orange and now we know how it tastes, and we would like to eat the other orange and see whether it tastes the same/better. Later on we can decide which one is better."

Dear goldenboy, as a general rule of thumb I do not react to responses from anonymous writers. However, you seem to be someone genuinely concerned and not any Tom, Dick and Harry (too many exist in Bhutanese social media). Kuensel Online is not the forum to share my life history but still a summary is necessary because in all innocence or ignorance or arrogance you alleged that I am a firm supporter of DPT.

I do not support any political party or personality. If you have had kept up over the years of my views you should know that I was the only private Bhutanese citizen (under my own name never anonymously) who publicly chided the last government for hiring McKinsey and for introducing the tobacco law. It was I who termed it, “draconian”. I also privately wrote to the Prime Minister to declare a national holiday to celebrate GNH and the Bhutanese family instead of public nuisance of weekly pedestrian days. A little more than a month later, the President of UN Assembly declared World Happiness Day. It seemed that UN heard me but my government did not. I still believe that this World Happiness Day now a public holiday in Bhutan can substitute for all pedestrian days if we bar all mechanical transports along with polluting factories from operating on the Happiness Day. It would be a far more effective and convenient way to promote clean environment for a happy Bhutanese family.

I also did write privately to the Prime Minister expressing my huge disappointment regarding government decision to withdraw Bhutan from the International Shanghai Trade Expo. In fact all the Countries in the world participated including India except for the two tiny countries, Bhutan and another the name of which I cannot recall right now.

The Sino-Bhutan relationship has been a very big concern to me since very early age when my father along with all men aged 15 years and above was called up by the 3rd King to defend the country in 1962 when Bhutan feared that Indo-China war that began at Tawang may spill over to Bhutan. I desire peace with both India and China. This was also what I submitted to His Majesty the 3rd King when he visited the Ugyen Wangchuck Academy at Paro. I was then 19 years old.  When His Majesty the 4th King made possible the signing of Sino-Bhutan Border Treaty, I thanked His Majesty from the bottom of my heart.  And again when His Majesty successfully renegotiated the 1949 Indo-Bhutan Treaty towards the end of his Reign, I was overjoyed. When the Prime Minister of Bhutan met with the Chinese Premier against the backdrop of Rio-Conference attended by so many world leaders, I felt that we have a Prime Minister who was following the vision of their Majesties the Kings. And yet it was shocking for me that we have Bhutanese who abused him for what actually is a giant step in Bhutan’s foreign relation and totally in keeping with the royal vision for Bhutan. I simply wish to give adequate time for Prime Minister Jigmi Y. Thinley to take the next forward step after the historic meeting with the Chinese Premier. Maybe he would be forced to abandon the process because we have huge anonymous voices that exercise super clout to dampen any tangible Sino-Bhutan relationship. It’s all for the future to see what he does.

I am very much pro India and I have much to be grateful to the Government and the People of India. We as a Nation and as Bhutanese individuals have come thus far and taken giant strides only because His Excellency Prime Minister Nehru of India took the arduous journey (trekking) to Bhutan to extend to the King of Bhutan and his subjects the hand of friendship from the Government and People of India. But the People of Bhutan and that of India must now be realistic. Bhutan and Bhutanese cannot ignore the larger than life existence of China physically overlooking Bhutan and towering over world economy and influencing the dynamic of International Politics. It is for this lifelong personal reason and future of Bhutan that I wish to support the GNH and Sino-Bhutan efforts of Prime Minister Jigmi Y. Thinley in his service to the King and the People of Bhutan.

I am dedicated only to Bhutan. I am the only Bhutanese who publicly prioritized Tsawasum in the order of Country, People and King because without Bhutan there cannot be Bhutanese and without Bhutan and Bhutanese people there cannot be a Bhutanese King. I am dedicated to the Wangchuck Dynasty because the past Kings have offered selfless and visionary services to the Kingdom and her people and the 5th King have committed to continue in the same path. I have always kept national interest at heart and my past deeds should substantiate that I stand only for Bhutan.

1)      I pioneered greater part of Bhutan Tourism development when it was really essential. Tourism started before I joined but all tourists came through travel agents in India. For several years they kept tour payments outstanding. And in 1977, when we insisted for payments, the travel agents in India backed by the Reserve Bank of India said, “Take the payment in rupees, Bhutan is not entitled to receive payments in dollars.”
Against all odds, but with Kenchhosum’s help, I managed to link up directly with foreign tour agencies and through sheer personal pleading and reasoning even got them to pay in dollars for all tourist groups that they had sent to Bhutan in the past years through travel agencies in India. (Go ahead and get your confirmation from those that worked under me or above me.)

2)      I met with the Joint Secretary North, External Affairs of India and successfully reduced Transit Permit issuance time from 3 months to 3 weeks for foreign tourists coming to Bhutan. In 1970s there was no Druk Air and foreign visitors had to travel through restricted areas of North India to reach Bhutan.

3)      I also worked as second-in-command in the Department of Trade, Industry and Mines during 1980s. Lyonpo Zimba was then the Director and Deputy Minister Lyonpo Om Pradhan was head of Trade and Industry Ministry. Late Dasho Dorji Tenzing was the Director General of Immigration and Census Department and Lyonpo Dago Tshering was the Deputy Minister of Home Affairs and direct boss of Dasho Dorji Tenzing. Deputy Ministry Lyonpo Chenkyap Dorji was Secretary of Planning Commission. Ask the surviving prominent 4 officials,”Who stood up in lone isolation for His Majesty’s vision of staffing the Trade and Industry sectors with Bhutanese people and doing away with dependence on foreign employees?”
Late Dasho Rinpochhe of Tashi Group was very angry. He could not understand why I had issued a letter which 3 Deputy Ministers agreed with him that I should not have. Lyonpo Leki Dorji the then Secretary to His Majesty the King was also there in Dasho’s residence as guest, quietly drinking beer. After 3 hours of firing me from 6 to 9pm he said this Haap does not even utter a word and ordered me to leave. I politely submitted that I will leave after having the dinner he had called me to attend. I had my way. I deeply respected Dasho Rinpochhe and understood his frustrations especially because the high officials supported him. However, as officiating Director I only had the powers to implement the policies and not exercise discretion.
Dasho Dorji Tenzing stood by the letter I had issued as officiating Director of Trade and Industry until he too felt overwhelming pressure which forced him to report to His Majesty that based on my letter he had not extended the working permit for Tashi Group’s some 400 foreign employees. His Majesty’s command was that he found my stand was in line with the policy. That ended the matter but before that I was ordered by my Minister to withdraw my letter which I refused. But I did tell Lyonpo Om Pradhan that as my Minister he could cancel my letter but he wanted Lyonpo Zimba then the Director to do it. He agreed but before he got around in issuing the superseding order, Dasho Dorji Tenzing conveyed His Majesty’s command. That was the beginning of the end of foreign domination especially in the Trade sectors. (I have given the names of concerned people only for the reason to enable skeptics to counter check facts.)

4)      Ask Bhutanese dolomite owners as to who had stood behind them and told the giant Steel Plants of India that dolomite was our produce therefore they cannot fix the price as it was customarily being done in the previous years. I did a background study and fixed a reasonable rate for per ton of dolomite (much higher than previous rates) and told them that they could buy or leave it. I remember that the mine owners like Mr. Omtey Penjor of present Yarkay Group and Dasho Pasang Dorji of present Karma Group and others were very nervous incase the Steel Plant representatives did not give in to our demand. Somehow I held my jittery group together and finally the representatives of the Steel Plants gave in. Since then it has been Bhutanese dolomite mine owners who set the rate for their produce and the buyers from India who negotiated. Before I came to Industry Department it was the other way. The Bhutanese dolomite selling rate was fixed by the Indian Steel Plants who purchased the dolomites.

5)      As a private citizen, it was I who stood for Bhutan’s policy and demanded that Danida office leave Bhutan because it had undermined my country’s sovereign power. ( I never subscribed to this business of police clearance but it was and is a national policy and I just could not take it when Danida flouted it.) I wrote to all relevant Ministries and Agencies including that of Donors and UN Agencies in Bhutan expressing my views on the undermining of Bhutan’s policy by Danida so that everyone will understand how a Bhutanese feels. I still recall the near shock response of the Danida resident representative, “I never met a Bhutanese like you until now.” My response was, “Until now you had not undermined Bhutan’s sovereignty.”

6)      On behalf of Haa people I had also publicly stated that the people of Haa had a historical dependence on Bhutan-Tibet Trade for the livelihood of their families.  And if any foreign groups or agencies disapproved of such historical ties, maybe they could provide alternate means.

7)       Most recently the heart of Haa was threatened by money mongers hungry for new mineral mines. Nobody spoke up for the communities affected by the proposed OMYA- RSA Mining Project at Haa Dragong. All 3 representatives of Haa people were silent. Lyonpo Tshering Tobgay and the Haa Dzongdha who joined PDP later were aware of the community sentiment. NC Dasho Tshering Dorji was aware of it and Dasho Doctor Gado Tshering, DPT candidate was also aware of it and yet nobody spoke publicly against the project because quite a few big shots and well to do Haaps were supporting the project. It was only the general public who realized that their very community life was threatened. They had approached the Dzongkhag authority that washed their hands off the problem stating that the project was approved by Central Government. As a Haap I had to join them. Together we decided to once again approach the Local Government and the Dzongkhag Administration and if necessary approach the concerned Ministry and as a last resort if no Administration responded, we decided to approach His Majesty the King. It now seems that the Interim Ministry is responding to the cries of the communities of Haa. For record much later, politician seeking votes opposed the project because by then they realized the gravity of public sentiment.

So my dear anonymous goldenboy, don’t you or any Bhutanese ever assume that I am a firm supporter of DPT party. I am a thorough bred senior Bhutanese. I have but one life to live and I live it as a Bhutanese. No one owns me but my Country and what I do or say in public is inspired by pure belief that it serves national interest. And by the way, whilst Lyonpo Tshering Tobgay is firming up to demonstrate his full leadership qualities, it is never too late because he is just around 42 years of age whilst Prime Minister Jigmi Y. Thinley is at his last shot at the Prime Minister’s post as per Constitutional dictates. And let me add that I deeply respect Dasho Nob Gyetse the father of Lyonpo Tshering Tobgay. Did you know that as a young RBG officer, it was he who arrested the assassin of the 1st Prime Minister of Bhutan His Excellency Jigme Palden Dorji? And now it is his son who is competing for the post of Prime Minister. Nobody can really say what awaits in the future!

And lastly in case you are too young to know I might as well tell you and those interested that I do posses some political insight and the necessary courage to state so because I do care for the well being of this nation. For example in 1998 when Cabinet was dissolved, I did publicly write and distribute a statement that I felt His Majesty the King was preparing for Democracy. And much later when the Constitution of Bhutan was being drafted, I wrote to the Chairman that having only two political parties in the General Election was not advisable for two reasons 1) It would not totally represent all the people of Bhutan and 2) That in such a small Country one political party could dominate and it might in the years to come, threaten the very core of national peace and stability i.e the Institution of Monarchy. Presently I do not see any such threat because our generation is still the part and parcel of the gift of Monarchy. I predicted the outcome of the Primary Election though I refrained from expressing in public. However, I did mention to those in close contact. My feeling was based on the domination of DPT and PDP in the public life of Bhutanese for the last 5 years and some very visible shortcomings of the other parties. But I must admit I am very impressed by the sheer gusto of the two women Presidents.

Sunday, June 2, 2013

Welcome to Political Reality exposed by Primary Election

The national Primary Election of Bhutan was held on 31st May, 2013. The voters in their infinite wisdom have decided to entrust the same national leader to lead and the opposition to oppose. The ambitious but little known group has been left wayside and the attractive spinster undated.

I reached Haa on 31st May afternoon to cast my vote and returned today to Thimphu. The people of Haa are happy for Lyonpo Tshering Tobgay the present favourite son of Haa. I could not vote for our outstanding Haap because we differ on Sino-Bhutan Policy. I yearn for Haa to be once again the Trade Route to China’s Tibet and for Bhutan as a whole to strengthen its sovereignty and exercise more independence in its India dominated foreign policy. I have more faith in Lyonchen Jigmi Yoezer Thinley at the national helm of governance. Bhutanese leadership must be more than Pro-India. They must be supremely Pro-Bhutan.

To certain extent I have a fair idea of politics in Bhutan but it is not correct for me to monopolize political forecast publicly. However, as a Haap, I shall comment on Haa politics. I met a friend on the way to Haa (Voting Day) and he told me that the mining issue has changed Haa politics. In hindsight it seems so. It is difficult for many voters to distinguish between local issue and national issue. I feel confident that mining issue can be tackled even when DPT comes back to power. In fact when my good friend Dr. Gado telephoned me for support I told him that I have national reasons to support DPT but he had better clarify (categorically) his position in this mining attack upon the communities of Haa. I do not know how he allayed public mining fear. In the televised forum he was vague. In fact I found out the fear was enhanced because there was a rumour that Lyonchen’s son was involved in the mining project.

I hope the poor DPT performance in Haa does not adversely affect Dr. Gado’s chance at the ministerial berth in the DPT Cabinet because he was leading DPT campaign in the two constituencies of Haa. Will he get elected in the General Election? Yes, it is my take on the ongoing political current of Haa.

Like most Haaps, I do admire Lyonpo Tshering Tobgay’s headlong push. Sometime early last year, I did write to him to move away from specialization in opposing and display more national leadership qualities. Like all self achievers, he did not take kindly to my view. But in the last 2 weeks of Primary Campaign, I saw a transformation. It was no more the figure of opposition. He spoke of his own dream for the nation and dwelt less on criticizing DPT. He appeared to be offering an alternate leadership and pushed himself to the limit covering 19 Dzongkhags in the process. It is a very good start and he has age on his side. A young voter in Haa told me on 1st June “the dream of a Prime Minister from Haa was shattered last night”. The dream need not end here, I feel. But for the time being for the next 5 years I pray that Lyonchen Jigmi Yoezer Thinley’s next government (after General Election) receives necessary support from the National Council and the Opposition Party to take Bhutan to prosperity and progress. 

Wednesday, May 22, 2013

An Internal Legal Auditor for ACC?


Both social and monetary corruption must be tackled and it will be a continuous battle for ACC. However is it time for ACC to have an in house independent  Legal Auditor Team comprising members with proven experience in legal, financial and administrative fields? This will reduce chances of ACC fomenting prosecution cases based on hearsay, suspicions, personal instincts and prejudices, public and political pressures. The conviction rate will also improve.

A deep introspection is called for since the much hyped anti-corruption case against health ministry’s doctors and officers has ended up being a wild goose chase (reference Kuensel 22nd May issues on High Court acquittal of the accused). Devoting huge financial, human and time resources of the Nation to prosecute the innocent, disregard established administrative process and procedure and bullying individuals and families into miseries and submission is not just horrendous but calls into question the supposed holistic stamp of Constitutional Bodies. Anticorruption campaign must not be a ‘crusade’. The term crusade is a Christian term to justify all means to convert the populace (heathens) to Christianity. Hounding the innocent is no fool proof deterrent to corruption.

Today with Constitutional Bodies in the person of Dasho (Aum) Neten Zangmo Chief Anti-Corruption Commissioner and the 4th Estate the media in person of Mr. Thinley Dorji, the Chief Executive Officer of Bhutan Broad Casting Service that invades every mind and home of Bhutan through its TV and radio networks hold Executive Power in day-to-day running of the Government. It blurs all lines of distinction between government administrative Agencies, constitutional institutions and the media.

Such situation of overlapping jurisdiction calls for strict discipline and code of conduct for individual Agencies in performing their professional tasks without prejudicing their interim extra-curricular authority or vice versa. And an independent internal legal auditor team could contribute corrective measures to prevent the tipping of scales to just one side. Internal checks or self examination can go a long way in bringing about cohesion within family and nation towards the royal guided GNH path.

Saturday, May 11, 2013

My thoughts on Party Presidents Meet, BBS TV, 8th May, 2013


It was lengthy by any standard but not much of a standard in content to compare to any other forum excluding NC candidates’ debate.

One could summarize that Chirwang was for younger leadership, Nyamrup for equity from inequity, Druk Phuensum for continuation and better days and People’s Democratic for a complete change. The ideologies are prerogatives of each individual political party and anyway their charter and manifesto are already approved by the Election Commission. So there is no comment.

However, just to excite my viewers on the blog, here are my views on some issues raised during the Presidents Meet.

1.       Leadership young or old
Democracy grants voters the choice of leadership. Therefore change in leadership cannot be granted or dictated by any Political Party or group of individuals. All can make their case to the people so that Bhutanese voters can make their choice of leadership.

2.       People must be alert lest power falls in the hands of one or two individuals
This concern was voiced quite frequently by most of the party presidents. That was revealing. When challenged by the former Prime Minister, PDP President said he was expressing future concern. Is there a concern among Bhutanese that the country may be heading towards dictatorship or revert to King’s rule due to political disarray?

3.       Rupee crisis and loans
Rupee crisis and loans will remain part of financial complexities for Bhutan no matter which Party comes to power. Progress and development need fund and our internal resources are limited. Even after 2020, it will not be possible to be free of loan or rupee crisis unless our external relationship dynamo changes and we receive major aid packages. Most Nations in the world are undergoing such monetary crisis even in developed European countries.

In my view if any Political Party assures continuous prosperity and at the same time fulfillment of people’s aspirations without loans and without rupee crisis, then there is one looming danger, the fate of Kingdom of Sikkim. No loans, no rupee crisis and no sovereignty but continuous development to meet social and economic needs of the people. India upholds all responsibilities for the state of Sikkim.

4.       Road and foreign relations
The former Prime Minister did not specifically make reference to these two subjects. In fact rural road condition issue was raised by PDP President. However, the President of DPT did state that the performance report of 1st Democratic Government was submitted to the nation in the last session of the Parliament. In that report it was highlighted that new motor roads exceeded all that were constructed prior to 2008. And diplomatic relation expanded greatly. Statistic figures were provided to illustrate the leaps and bounds.

I felt that comparison of pre and post 2008 developments in road and diplomatic relationship need to be delicately handled and especially accurately and realistically recorded. Many view such declaration as unfair criticism of past government under the 3rd and 4th Kings.

The fact is that any and all diplomatic efforts of the 1st Democratic Government pales in comparison to membership to Colombo Plan, United Nations, Non-Aligned, SAARC, many international organizations and opening of international agency offices within Bhutan. During the reigns of the 3rd and 4th King, diplomatic relationship was purposefully restricted to the most indispensible and beneficial to the Kingdom of Bhutan.

The fair weather road connections to almost all geogs of the Kingdom is admirable and even if some of these roads are not pliable during snow and rain yet I am sure unlike the sneering urbanites, the farmers in rural Bhutan are very grateful. The farmers would rather have a fair weather road than no road at all.
Due to budget, time and human resource constraints, such farm roads had to be of fair weather condition. However, it will be easier for the next government to improve upon what have been laid already. Likewise during the government lead by the Kings, other priorities and pressing urgencies had to be met from limited financial and human resources. And because so many essential social and economic needs were fulfilled prior to 2008, these very achievements enabled the 1st Democratic Government to fulfill majority of their commitments.

5.        Relationship with India is non-negotiable was one of the declared political stand
Indo-Bhutan relation has always been and probably will ever be always the corner stone of Bhutan’s foreign policy. Bhutan cannot forsake India under any circumstance and India should realize the futuristic wisdom of allowing Bhutan necessary sovereignty in its foreign relation especially with China.
However in so far as relationship is concerned be it personal, national, international (bilateral or multi lateral) are negotiable. There is no such thing as status quo (stagnation) or non-negotiable. Relationships have to mature, improve, change for better and be in tune with the changing time, maturity and aspirations of individuals, groups and nations etc.

Sino-Bhutan Relationship was not directly mentioned but indirectly the declared political stand “Indo-Bhutan relation is non-negotiable” maybe alluding to anonymous sources’ criticism of Lyonchen Jigmi Y Thinley meeting with Chinese Premier.

I have always respected India and will always remain grateful to Prime Minister Nehru for making the arduous journey to give birth to Indo-Bhutan friendship. However, I am in favour of better relation with China. My feelings on Sino-Bhutan relation was made public long before the advent of Bhutanese Democracy.

Sino-Bhutan relation has always been a concern to Bhutan since ages and more so from the time Tibet became an autonomous region of China. We have held many sessions of border talks in the most cordial atmosphere and officials of both countries have exchanged visits. In the Sino-Bhutan Border Agreement, we have committed to promote friendly relations between the two countries

No nation in the world is ignoring China. Our next door ASEAN neighbour Myanmar has finally broken the trade and diplomatic embargo imposed by the West only because China did not fail Myanmar. The public pretext of European and American overtures to Myanmar is participation of Aung San Suu kyi in politics but actually the same military government holds sway even today. One could close the eyes and wish away reality. But even those blind in-sights cannot refrain from sensing the dominating presence of the world’s most populace, resource rich and influential China. Therefore, I hope that whichever Party comes to power in the next session, Bhutan will have progressive relationship with China. By this it does not necessarily mean that DPT has to return. After all, the 1st Democratic Government has been unable to push through the exchange of establishment of Embassies between Bhutan and Japan. Japan was ready yesterday but Bhutan hesitates even though we have diplomatic relation and Japan has been much economic help for decades. I personally think that Mao Khola Bridge and possibly other major funding from Japan await the exchange of Embassies of the two countries.  

Wishing everybody everyday politicking in this season of Primary and General Elections. Good luck and great speculations!




Salutation to His Holiness the 70th Jhe Khenpo Trulku Jigme Chhoeda.


Coinciding with the welcome arrival today of the Dratsang to Thimphu from its winter residence in Punakha, I wish to share the salutation I had drafted in August, 2012 after attending the Thri-Lung-Wang in Haa Dzongkhag. His Holiness has many followers within and outside the Kingdom of Bhutan and in sharing my thoughts I hope to hear from other disciples their sentiments.

In the name of Dharma, propagation of faith in Buddha and promotion of peace and the well-being of Bhutan, I humbly offer salutation to the greatest of living Buddhist Saint, your Holiness Trulku Jigme Chhoeda.

1.       Your Holiness has travelled the length and breadth of this Kingdom and have bestowed upon the   multitudes of Bhutanese of all walks of life the opportunity to receive Thri-Lung-Wang Blessings.

2.       In the history of Bhutan no Saint has been able to bring the Teaching of Lord Buddha to doors of so many households in such a short span of time. The people of 20 Dzongkhags are fortunate that such a Jhe Khenpo presides over the Institution of Buddhism in Bhutan.

3.       Your Holiness has the unique knack of relating Buddhist Teaching to scientists and house wives, to everyday life happening and historical events, to both Buddhist and non Buddhists.

4.     And your Holiness possesses the energy of the ocean. I just cannot comprehend how it is ever possible to impart teaching from dawn to dusk, everyday and in every Dzongkhag. Age 57 is well past those energetic 20’s and 30’s and yet the serene smile, the compassionate composure and social enthusiasm with the unique dharmic voice never diminishes.

5.   Cremation was the most problematic task that faced bereaved families. Now thanks to benevolent rules introduced and implemented (yes implemented which is the most important part of a rule), cremation procedure is so simple if one is satisfied with simplicity. One needs fire wood, a match stick and the corpse for funeral. Everything else is done by the Drastang in the twenty Dzongkhags. But ofcourse if the bereaved family wishes to show case the funeral, then it involves more money to pitch colourful tents, arrange banquet for hundreds of guests who come with gifts, seek special Wongku Lopen and construct new impressive Thakur.

The Mitruk Lhakhang at the Thimphu cremation area is a wonderful refugee for all the disadvantaged families and the lost souls of their members that need direction to the next world through the period of void. I wish that the Royal Government is more forth coming in copying the exemplary venture that your Holiness has under taken with Mr. Shamab Rinchen, in other Dzongkhags.

At the national level, I wish to express my deep gratitude for the televised appearances that your Holiness made to console and provide moral and spiritual strength to the nation during last year earthquake and the Wangdue Dzong destruction by fire. It was thoughtfully gracious of your Holiness to share the public fears that such natural disasters inflict and attempt to fill the void that hearts cannot escape from experiencing.

I now have realized that the Drastang has a special role in the hearts of the people during such national crisis. When such fear and losses strike, the direct and allied victims feel haunted and hopeless. An honest approach to such calamity is the best condolence. At their weakest moment, people do not want to hear official interpretation and censored news. Your Holiness provided a much needed truth and consolation. I also wish to thank and express my appreciation to the Zhung Drastang Lopen who was heartbroken and publicly spoke the truth -“a lot of Nangtens could not be saved”.

Initially the official and BBS version was as if the fire of Wangdue Dzong was prearranged. The Dzong burnt away as if it was a temporary hut made of bamboo mats and yet the officials and news broadcast claimed all relics were saved. Why does victims need to be further victimized by more lies? There is something so rotten with some people’s way of addressing national grief.

Please your Holiness continue the way you and the Lopen had approached the calamity regardless of how bad the situation was and how much grief would be further caused by the truth. The people of Bhutan have the right to know the truth.  How do people regain their faith and trust if they are deceived in their weakest moment by their own officials and news channels? 

Now as a Haap, I wish to touch upon what seems to be a historical bond between Miriphensum, Ap Chhundu and Trulku Jigme Chhoeda.  Haa just happened to be the first to receive Thri Lung Wang from the 70th Jhe Khenpo. And Haa I think just happened to be the first to be blessed with the 1st Moenlam Chhenmo by the 70th Jhe Khenpo. (May I thank your Holiness for enabling the built up of Haa Moenlam Chhenmo fund and for so graciously blessing the system I had set up for proper management of the fund). It seems Haa also just happened to be in the western most part of Bhutan and yet have so many devotees from other Dzongkhags come and sponsor events and offer Ku Sung Thue Mindrel during Moenlam Chhenmos and especially during this year’s Thri Lung Wang. Somehow religious events in Haa conducted and blessed by Trulku Jigme Chhoeda always had a flair of festivity, happiness, rainbow adorned sun, the orderly flow of the events and the pureness of mind and soul that forms an unbreakable chain link between the guru and the devotees.

How can we Haaps ever thank your Holiness for all the days of “enlightenment that Haaps experience” every year for that brief duration of your visit? If someone else told me about it, I would have taken it as a great fairy tale too good to be true. I feel most fortunate to be one of the many grateful Haaps to be so privileged. 

 Miracles I feel fortunate to be a part of during the Thri Lung Wang at Haa from 2nd to 18th July, 2012.

1.    The recitation part was over for the day and explanation talk to help ordinary devotees to comprehend the teaching was about to begin. It was raining heavily and the sound of rain falling on the tin roof rather deafening. His Holiness says, “I will try to get through to you despite the sound of the rain”. Suddenly as if it was controlled like tap water, the thudding roof sound softened. I looked out, the shower had just turned to drizzle and within 5 or so minutes, it stopped completely.

2.       In our village, household members don’t sleep at night. They are out patrolling the fields against wild animals. And yet invariably the next day someone’s field has been devastated. Then three days into the Thri Lung Wang, when I returned home at 7 pm, there was smile. The reason “the fields were untouched last night”. And so it continued even the next day. After the 5th day, I asked people from other villages and they too confirmed the sudden halt to marauding wild animals.

3.     His Majesty the King visited Haa and came to see His Holiness. All devotees were seated in the arena of wang complex. What I noticed was a strong breeze out of nowhere as if to announce the presence of invisible deities and petered off gently as the two temporal and spiritual personalities sat in the antechamber next to the Kikhor. Later others tell me of double rainbow around the sun. A friend had even taken a photo to show around. Definitely a good omen for His Majesty, His Holiness and the Nation.

4.     The religious programs start at 5:30 am and end at 6 pm. There were breaks for 25 minutes at 9:30 am and 3:30 pm. And lunch break from 12:30 pm to 2 pm. It did rain in Haa as it rained in other parts of the country but somehow as devotees travelled to attend the blessing in the early mornings or returned to place of residence late evenings, there was no rain to hinder. I never had to use an umbrella to take my breaks which is a rare convenience in the mist of monsoon.

Most devotees felt these were miracles performed by the Jhe Khenpo. I felt otherwise. I do not think His Holiness would want to interfere with the working of the nature. But someone was controlling the weather. That’s for sure. I think it was the Deities of Haa who were being exceptional host to their exceptional guest His Holiness Jhe Khenpo.

His Holiness shares close affinity with Haaps and their Deities. The Deities welcome and protects him and the people of Haa, a few years ago, even requested His Holiness to become a Haap and have census under the Haa Dzongkhag. I don’t think we Haaps should be so selfish. We have to share His Holiness with all others though it is our prayer and wish that the annual blessings in Haa be always an occasion to renew our love and reverence for His Holiness and receive blessings from him.
  
The Title of Jhe Khenpo in Bhutan

I remember reading some articles in the past where heads of other buddhist sects or high lamas and trulkus were referred to as ‘Jhe Khenpo’. This type of trend is both confusing and disturbing. In the Kingdom of Bhutan, there is only one holy person who has the right to hold this title, ‘Jhe Khenpo’ and that is the Head of the Central Monastic Body of Bhutan. I feel that the Ministry of Home & Cultural Affairs needs to put emphasis on this decorum which should be followed by all those residing or visiting Bhutan.

His Holiness was addressed as ‘Yishey Norbu’ by the Tibetan Drastang educated Khenpo Tandin Situ of Haa during his off the sermon very entertaining talks to the public in Haa. The salutation ‘Yishey Norbu’ is generally used by Tibetans for His Holiness the Dalai Lama. I agree that Trulkus are in a way jewel of god but let ‘Yishey Norbu’ be the accepted reference for His Holiness the Dalai Lama and let us the Bhutanese preserve and protect the title of Jhe Khenpo for our Head of the Central Monastic Body. Let us not corrupt or dilute the unique references. I think the saying ‘to each his own’ is a good advice to follow. The other Trulkus in Bhutan, regardless of Buddhist sects, must acknowledge that there is only one Jhe Khenpo title in Bhutan and that is the official title for the Head of the Central Monastic Body of Bhutan just as the title of Druk Gyalpo is for the King of Bhutan.

Buddhism in Bhutan

As a citizen of Bhutan, I am very proud of our King, our Dratsang and our democratic government. I realize that the Dratsang is financially well endowed and well regarded by His Majesty the King and the Council of Ministers led by the Hon’ble Prime Minister. His Majesty the King and the Cabinet have diligently stood by the age old tradition of paying their homage to the Shabdrung instituted Dratsang every time the winter and summer change of residence takes place for the Kham Soum Singye and the Dratsang led by His Holiness the Jhe Khenpo.

Buddhism is an integral part of Bhutan and is the soul of sovereignty, culture and tradition. Its part and parcel of Bhutan and Bhutanese life as is the snow on the summit of Mount Jhomolhari throughout the seasons of spring, summer, autumn and winter. Did any Bhutanese see Jhomolhari without its snow cap or for that matter does anyone want the snow cap to melt and suffer the consequences of eco-system collapse?  The Constitution of Bhutan has taken away this soul of Bhutan. Buddhism has been relegated from its centuries old position as the State religion of Bhutan. It was Buddhism that nurtured and consolidated the Kingdom that we now cherish as our Home and Country. How can we disown the very architect of our unique existence?  I have pleaded in vain against this act of monumental sacrilege and gross breach of Thadamtsi. However my voice is a cry in the wilderness and so never heard. And yet I continue to do so because I believe the echo in the wilderness can still be heard by Kuenchosoum if not by people.  A good seed thrown into the wind will take root someday, somewhere to bear fruit. And a good thought if uttered in all goodness of tradition will someday make possible the crowning of lotus upon the ocean of Bhutanese polity.

I hope that in the foreseeable future, the leaders of Bhutan and the legislators will take unto their consideration the absolute necessity of reinstating Buddhism to its national status for the wellbeing of Bhutan and the Bhutanese people.  I do not think that we need to chop our head to fit the new cap of constitutional monarchy.

Dratsang is not a political institution and monks are barred from political activities including voting. This I think, in a way, is in keeping with the tradition. The Dratsang has had no direct role post Shabdrung era as to which Penlop killed which Penlop and then occupied the national administrative seat of the Deb Raja. But all Deb Rajas still revered Buddhism as the State religion. I do not think any foreign nation or new religious groups that crop up in Bhutan has any spiritual or moral right let alone political right to demand otherwise. Buddhism as State Religion of Bhutan does not in any way hinder the practice and spread of other religions in the Kingdom.

May our Kingdom be always blessed with truly Holy Souls representing Lord Buddha like His Holiness Trulku Jigme Chhoeda.


Sunday, April 28, 2013

In remembrance of Dasho Zillnon Dorji Wangchuck


It was reported that the car he drove went off the highway near Ganglakha in the early morning of 18th April, 2013. This stretch of Phuentsholing Thimphu highway between Sorchen and Jumdra area is prone to foggy weather. There could be many reasons for the fatal accident like fast driving which most young people do without such fatal consequences. It could, however, very well be low visibility in the early hour fog.

Dasho is the son of Her Royal Highness Princess Dechen Wangmo Wangchuck and Dasho Thinley Dorji. But a straight forward short cut comprehension of who he really is would be to simply state that Dasho Zillnon Dorji Wangchuck is the 1st grandchild of their Majesties King Jigme Dorji Wangchuck (the 3rd King of Bhutan) and Her Majesty Queen Kesang Choeden Wangchuck. By Bhutan’s strict official definition he is not a royalty but royal blood definitely gave birth to him. This paradox of birth - being neither royal nor commoner can be as confounding and difficult to adjust as would be an unprepared person of a tropical region teleported suddenly to a hostile tundra region. Dasho being the 1st grandchild, he was old enough to remember the grand old days but not mature enough to cope with the social changes in status that came about in the 1990’s. For anyone, I feel, it is a tragedy to have to travel through a no-man land. And it is much more difficult if one had never been prepared for such a trek.

 I met Dasho in person few years back, lean, handsome and charmingly soft spoken. Dasho’s resemblance to the 4th King amazed me. By then he had his share of life’s joy and sorrow, love, wives and children. I believe he had on occasion darker moods but generally a gregarious personality of immense goodwill and passionate character so I am told.

I wondered what kind of funeral it would be that day on Thursday the 25th of April, 2013 at Thimphu crematorium. It was a sobering day not much sun and no rain but it was a royal funeral. Thankfully and rightfully, blood triumphed over official dictates. His Holiness Thrulku Jigme Choedra, the 70th Jhe Khenpo led the Mitruk prayers with the venerable Lopons and monks of Central Monastic Body. Life after death could be anyone’s guess but it is generally believed that when Mitruk prayer is offered by such a holy lam as His Holiness Jhe Khenpo, the deceased does make a brief appearance. If so Dasho Zillnon would have appreciated the royal honour offered in death. Along with his immediate family members, almost all members of four generations of the royal families were present led by His Majesty the 4th King. They were all soberly dressed as befitting bereaved families.

Unlike the royal bereaved members, I was dressed differently like few other attendees. It was an important day for me. The Kings have been gracious to me and as a senior Bhutanese citizen and subject of the Kings, I wanted to be properly attired to be presentable when making the final adieu to the royal grandson, royal nephew and royal cousin of the Kings of Bhutan. I took my bath, wore my ancient bura gho, and purified a note of 100, 10 and 5 ngultrums with incense smoke and holy water from the bumpa. If an occasion presented, I intended to pay my respects before the make shift alter customarily placed in front of every funeral pyre. If not I decided to make the offering to the Thimphu river flowing nearby. After all, the ash from the pyre ultimately would have to be immersed in a River.

But an occasion did present itself. I approached the alter decked with offerings, and Dasho’s photo so alive and noble looking placed on the top-most choetri. I bowed, lowered my kabney till the frills touched the sacred ground, offered the Nu: 100 note in lieu of a khaddar and wished Dasho a less complicated and more comforting next life. Then I approached the already lit funeral pyre and offered the NU: 15 as part of Dasho’s offering (chhan-jay) to the next world Lam who will guide his path.

Much later, I had the honour and privilege of being graciously hugged by His Majesty the 4th King. I wanted to say how sorry I was but the air was already heavy with sorrow and loss. Instead I held the royal person in embrace a second longer than correct protocol. But protocol was far away from the scene of a royal life cruelly felled mid-way and now within a burning pyre.

No outsider can fathom the pain of bereavement. But still I hope as time goes by, it becomes bearable for those near and dear ones left behind so suddenly. I hope Dasho’s children successfully go through school and college so that they would be prepared to fend for themselves along with other citizens of their age. When one is neither royal nor a commoner, the most advisable approach would be to get a good education, mingle with the crowd and learn the ways of both societies. The nobleness will remain within the blood regardless of official definition and practical experiences, education and exposures would provide the required impetus to cope with both the world of the royal and the citizen society of Bhutan.

I humbly offer my prayers to the bereaved royal members especially to Her Highness the royal mother and Her Majesty the Queen Grandmother of Dasho Zillnon. Her Majesty, Grand Queen Mother Kesang Choeden Wangchuck has sacrificed so much and borne so much pain for the Nation, the royal families and now this personal tragedy. I hope the royal mother and the royal grandmother will find solace and comprehension of life in the Buddhist scriptures and prayers.

Wednesday, April 17, 2013

Hear, Hear ye all whoever care to hear!


Occasionally all so unexpectedly, one is so deeply exposed to another person’s thought and emotion. Many years back, I saw a televised event wherein the present Emperor of Japan was remembering his late father Emperor. The Emperor poetically mourned the absence of his father though the four seasons of Winter, Spring, Summer and Autumn appeared as usual. This experience, I feel sure, added an extra dimension to my love and reverence for my parents.

Today I was quite overcome by the Bishop of London, His Eminence Richard Chartres. The Bishop was remembering ‘Iron Lady’ Margaret Thatcher, former Prime Minister of Britain, during her funeral service.

Margaret Thatcher is considered to be a most controversial and polarizing politician who dominated British and to some extent international politics for over a decade. She overcame prejudices against, “women especially women with children”. However, when she got the top job, she was mother of arrogance to many of her colleagues who finally ganged up and sent her packing to retirement. And for the next 2 decades or so, she led a near reclusive life especially after suffering a stroke in early 1990’s and then loss of her beloved husband Denis Thatcher. Fate is a mixture of sweet and sour soap.

In death ( April 8th ) the international media again racked up old wounds but today at St. Paul’s Cathedral, the Bishop of London called upon the gathering of dignitaries, politicians, family members, friends and political adversaries to let it be. “It is not a memorial service, it is a simple funeral service as requested by her”, he said. “The time is for compassion and not political difference,” he implored.  

The cathedral housed more than 2000 mourners headed by Her Majesty Queen of England and Duke of Edinburgh. There were family members, Prime Ministers of Britain, past and present, Head of governments and representatives of over 170 Countries. Henry Kissinger was also there. The Archbishop of Canterbury was there to offer prayers. It was impressive and it was a state funeral in all sense. The Britons really know how to come together and showcase memorable historical events.

To this august gathering of mourners, the Bishop of London admitted that Thatcher was a controversial and polarizing figure but she did successfully serve Britain and the British when it mattered. This same sentiment was also expressed by Prime Minister Cameron a few days earlier, “She was there when our country needed most”.

The Bishop offered his condolences to the family members ( children and grandchildren ) and dedicated friends of the late Prime Minister especially to those “who stood by her side in later years”.

His Eminence Richard Chartres looks much younger than Mrs. Thatcher but it seems they were good personal friends and confidants. He talked of Margaret Thatcher’s view of individual and religion. He recounted that Margaret Thatcher said that Christianity did not provide political and economic solutions and that she had also said “Happiness and Salvation cannot be achieved in isolation but only as part of a society”.

I feel fortunate and enriched by experiencing this live telecast from the St. Paul’s Cathedral, London. And I reverently salute the Bishop of London, a religious personality with immense political knowledge and great eloquence that brought about a healing touch to the living and a memorial tribute to Baroness Margaret Thatcher. Perhaps in his memorial address, he succeeded in bringing about the personal side of the former Prime Minister without alienating her political adversaries and providing a much needed conciliatory gesture to enable a great nation to remember an extraordinary woman. Sometimes it is a great relief to find a person of such nature who uses extraordinary talent and humanness to bring dignity to a society often torn apart by political differences.

Saturday, April 6, 2013

The Gyalpozhing Land Case.

The trial court in Mongar passed its verdict. It seems neither side was satisfied. Critics thought it was too lenient and the penalized people thought it was unfair. The cases are under appeal in High Court. And now it’s the turn of the four High Court Drangpons to centre stage the nation.
                                                          
The cases are between two sets of authorities: The Committee for Land allotment and the Anti Corruption Commission. The former is accused of high jacking the “Kasho” and the latter whose commissioners are now in their 7th or 8th year of supreme reign against the constitutional 5 year tenure is accused of high jacking legitimacy. And out in the open air, we the public spectators are ever ready to swing with the wind and also enjoy pot-shots.

The appeal courts - High Court and Supreme Court, may now need to examine just more than what accusers and the accused have stated in the trial court.

The basic question is why was the committee formed? If it was simply to allot plots as per the command then there was no need to set up a committee. The Dzongda, as representative of the King, was there to implement straight forward directives.

Were the committee members paid sitting fee like Board Directors of a corporation? If so, it was an additional responsibility with additional pay, therefore, each member is accountable. If no fee were paid, then the work of the committee was an additional burden and is it reasonable or fair to demand that a beast of burden carry more than its share of baggage?

I have heard a saying something like ‘Justice must not only be done but must also be seen to be done’ It validates the essentialities of general perception. A widely held perception is a law unto itself. It influences people’s thoughts and actions and paves way for general acceptance.

Presently the national land commission holds sway over all private land holding in urban and rural areas. However a few years back, it was not so. The Town Committees allotted land and the Town administrations registered or deregistered plots in urban areas. There existed unquestionable general perception that Town Committees had the necessary authority over urban plot allotment and registration.

If the plots are to be allotted only to the original land owners then the very land should have been left in the possession of original owners. The Government could have developed the plots and charged the costs to the land owners or in lieu take possession of the part of the land holding as development cost. And if the plots were to be allotted only to business license holders, how does that benefit the original land holders? And anyways who really are the license holders? These people are not necessarily original inhabitants from the locality. Most are fast track people with financial means and acquired knowledge to complete the required formalities to possess business license, in time to get plots. Therefore, should the so called influential people or cousins be less eligible than shrewd businessman or an alerted acquaintance who acquired timely business license.

The indisputable facts are:
  1. The original land holders lost out in all the declared modern urban areas from Gyalpozhing to Khuruthang to Bajothang and countless other urban areas. The law and administrators just chose to pay minimum compensation and take away the land. After that whether a minister got a plot or a mistress got a plot or a business man got a plot, it really does not impact the life of the original land owner.
  2.  Those who have the financial means and necessary connections bought plots through allotments and maybe few could have got plots without payment through Kidu process.
  3. The accepted norm in the past for acquiring plots in declared urban areas was to apply to the Town committee. Everyone high, middle or low followed the procedure because general perception was that the Town Committee was the authority for plot allotments.
Whatever “Kasho” or even letter of Zonal Administrator that are being cited in the ongoing case were not available in public domain. Therefore only three authorities were and are equipped to interpret these documents - the two issuing authorities and one implementing authority.

Like other lay men, I am impressed with legal jargons used by lawyers fighting the case but Drangpons from same schools as that of prosecuting and defending lawyers might not so easily be impressed or stupefied.

The crux of the debates between opposing lawyers are the interpretation of Kasho and zonal administrator’s letter. Did these documents empower the committee? Did the committee error?

Now will the High Court provide the interpretation of the nuances of the Kasho and that of the zonal order? Would the judicial interpretation be in line with the thought and intent of the originators of the Kasho and zonal letter? Is it necessary or advisable for sake of delivering Justice to seek views of the originators before any Agency or Court goes ahead in its interpretation of the implied meanings / nuances of the documents especially when the accused parties are disputing the opinions of the prosecuting Agency?

Precedence: In Judiciary, past verdicts on similar cases does matter. Prior to this Land committee case, there was a construction committee case. Not just any construction committee, it was the committee for Supreme Court construction.

A drangpon of the then highest Court of the Land (High Court) was a member of the committee. According to media report, Supreme Court’s verdict was that the committee erred and in fact manipulated to award the contract to a particular construction firm. The Supreme Court directed High Court to order concerned Ministry (Work and Human Settlement) to take disciplinary action against committee members. The matter ended with that Ministry issuing a reprimand note to those committee members still under civil service. Upon legal complaint by another aggrieved party, the tender was cancelled and recalled and the contract given to other parties. Likewise in Gyalpozhing case, it is possible to revert back the allotted plots to government ownership if there were compromise of norms. Thus in both cases lasting damage is prevented / preventable.

In terms of monetary value, the Supreme Court construction could well exceed the total proceeds that Government received from the allotment of Gyalpozhing plots. A Government Committee is a committee whether of land or construction. If the Land committees erred, can the penalty be different from that of the construction committee that had erred and compromised norms.

In a court of Law, the standard of process and basis for Justice should hold true and same for both a doorman or a cabinet minister or a committee. Equal Justice under Law cannot remain a decorative plaque heeded only occasionally nor is it fair on one’s part to demand leniency for some and harsh penalty for some because before the law, it is assumed that all are equal.

Sangey of Haa Wangcha